Underwriting explained
By Allstate
Last updated: January 0001
Key points
- Underwriting is the process of assessing the risk of a venture and determining the terms and price an institution (or investor) will require to assume that risk.
- It comes in several forms, including loan underwriting, securities underwriting, and insurance underwriting.
- Underwriting can be manual, involving human judgment and is more flexible but slower, or automated, using algorithms for quicker assessments but is less flexible (especially in complex cases).
- It affects various aspects of personal finance, from securing mortgages and insurance policies to determining the terms of loans and premiums.
Imagine you're buying your first home and you need to apply for a mortgage. You've provided all of the necessary documentation, but before you receive your final approval letter, your lender needs to go through the process of underwriting your application. This behind-the-scenes evaluation happens in many scenarios, including when you apply for insurance or certain types of investments.
Learn more about one of the financial world's most important concepts, how it works, and what it means for you.
What is underwriting?
Underwriting is the process of measuring a risk of a certain venture and coming up with the price and terms that an institution or investor would require to undertake that risk, explains The Economic Times.
The word underwriting comes from the practice of having risk takers write their name below the total risk that they undertake in return for a specified premium in the early stages of the industrial revolution.
Types of underwriting
Underwriting is a practice that underpins many ventures spanning numerous industries. Here are some of the common types of underwriting.
Loan underwriting
Whether you are a company or an individual applying for a mortgage or personal loan from a bank or other financial institution, they will underwrite your application to determine appropriate terms for your agreement, explains AgSouth Farm Credit.
The primary goal in loan underwriting is to determine the likelihood that a borrower will repay their loan. Analysts will typically look at the borrower's credit history, financial state, capacity to repay the loan, and general market conditions during the process. This informs their decision around the terms of repayment.
Securities underwriting
In investment banking, underwriting pertains to the process that investment banks follow to raise capital for corporations through securities, like stocks or bonds, says the Corporate Finance Institute.
In this context, underwriters assess the financial health of the organization issuing the security, potential risks, and determine the appropriate pricing for the security, according to Wallstreet Oasis.
Insurance underwriting
Insurance underwriting is a method of quantifying the insurance risk of a certain policy and setting premiums at an appropriate price given that risk. Insurance risk is defined as the potential that the insurer will have to cover the agreed upon insured event, explains Insuranceopedia.
Insurance underwriting helps set premiums by understanding three core factors:
- The probability that the insured event will happen
- The severity of the event and financial loss event
- The amount of risks that the insurer assumes liability for
For a classic example, insurance premiums grow higher as you age because of the overall likelihood of health complications rising with age.
How does underwriting work?
Going back to the definition of underwriting, fundamentally, we are talking about the process of assessing the appropriate cost for an individual or organization to assume the risk of a venture. The specifics can vary widely depending on the type of venture be that a personal loan, mortgage, car insurance, or dealing in securities, according to The Economic Times. The typical framework is something like this:
- The entity assuming risk will typically ask for documentation about the relevant facts and circumstances around the venture.
- The underwriter will use these facts to decide whether or not it is appropriate to take the risk and if so, the price of doing so.
Underwriting and insurance
Underwriting in insurance is similar to underwriting in other areas. Underwriters determine whether a potential insurer should take the risk of insuring a client, how much insurance should be offered, and whether offering a policy is appropriate to begin with.
Factors that impact car insurance underwriting
The factors that impact car insurance underwriting are vast and constantly changing based on the best available information, according to the NAIC. However, some factors remain fairly consistent, such as:
- Age. Younger drivers have been shown to get into more accidents on average than older, more experienced drivers.
- Gender. Males have been shown to get into more accidents than female drivers.
- How the vehicle is used. If you only drive lightly then your pricing may be cheaper than those who use their vehicle more heavily.
- Location. If you keep your car secured in a garage. The rate of theft, accidents, or adverse weather may impact your underwriting.
- Coverage history. If you have gaps in your coverage history it is possible that insurers will charge you more.
- Driving habits and history. The driving habits of yourself and anyone else on your policy might impact your underwriting. For example, if you have recent traffic violations or have been in an accident.
- Credit history. Insurance companies may use information about your credit history when they rate your policy.
Factors that impact life insurance underwriting
Like with any other type of underwriting, there are numerous things that are taken into consideration when underwriting life insurance, explains FEDmanager. These factors may include:
- Age. Generally speaking younger people will have lower rates than older people.
- Medical history. Your medical history and current conditions can also impact your rates by informing the risk of certain conditions occurring or reoccurring.
- Family medical history. Your immediate family's medical history also helps inform insurance agencies of the likelihood of a loss event.
Manual vs automated underwriting
Underwriting can be done with manual and automated processes. These processes have different strengths and weaknesses that make them suitable for specific situations.
Manual underwriting
Manual underwriting is when a human underwriter reviews each underwriting case and assesses the risk factors manually. This can be suitable in complex risk assessment situations or in small scale cases.
Pros
- More personalized evaluation
- Greater flexibility for navigating complex cases
Cons
- Manual underwriting takes longer than automated underwriting
- Can be susceptible to human error
Automated underwriting
Automated underwriting relies on machines to use algorithms and data models to assess risk and make decisions quickly. This can make automated underwriting ideal for less complex underwriting particularly at scale, according to Lonestar Financing.
Pros
- Reliable, data-driven decisions
- Fast assessment and approval process
Cons
- Less flexibility for unique or complex cases
- Can be rigid in decision making
How underwriting affects you
Underwriting affects many of the ventures people undertake on a regular basis. It determines not only if applicants qualify for mortgages, personal loans, and insurance policies, but also the rates and terms. That means that underwriting impacts individuals' finances in almost all aspects of life from dwelling to driving.
Tips for improving your underwriting profile
Improving your underwriting profile can lead to better insurance rates and loan approvals. While some of these factors are external, there are some steps that you can take to improve your profile and your results in these endeavors.
For car insurance
The NAIC provides the following tips that may help improve your underwriting profile for car insurance:
- Drive responsibly, maintain a clean driving record
- Keep your car in a secure location
- Maintain good credit or improve it
For life insurance
Improving your underwriting profile for life insurance may require a larger commitment, but the FEDmanager recommends these two things:
- Maintain a healthy lifestyle
- Take a proactive approach to healthcare with regular health screenings
For loans
AgSouth Farm Credit recommends these three tips for potentially improving your underwriting profile for loans:
- Maintain good credit history
- Pay your loans on time
- Ensure you have adequate capacity to pay the loan that you are applying for
Underwriting FAQs
Underwriting can take variable amounts of time depending on whether or not it is undergoing a manual or automated underwriting process, the complexity of the situation, and the required documentation. For example a mortgage can take up to a month to underwrite, says Rocket Mortgage.
To help underwriting go as quickly and smoothly as possible, ensure that you know what is required and assemble the appropriate documentation so you can submit it as part of your application.
Underwriting is used in almost any situation where you would want to quantify the risk of something occurring so you can price the risk of assuming the liability of it happening. For this reason, underwriting is seen in numerous places and has become a sort of discipline in and of itself. Underwriting is used in issuing mortgages, life insurance policies, weather insurance, personal loans, crop prices, and beyond.
Yes. Underwriting is required to understand the risk an insurer undertakes when they choose to issue insurance. This helps them determine fair terms including premiums, coverage amounts, etc.
Yes. There are cases where an underwriter has gone through the process of assessing the risk for a policy or loan and that risk is just too high. Maybe the person's credit score is unacceptably low or someone is seeking insurance on a vehicle with several DUIs. In cases like these, an underwriter may deny coverage.
Underwriting for self-employed individuals may be different due to numerous factors but a big one is that your income may be more volatile than someone working a traditional job. In these cases, you may be required to present additional documentation or have a higher credit score.