Law Office of Carroll, Stephan, Tucy, Goldstein and Goldberg

This office is not a partnership or a corporation.
Wooden gavel with Allstate logo

We're here to help

The attorneys in this office limit their practice to defending lawsuits against people like you who are insured by Allstate or one of their subsidiaries. They represent you and will exercise independent professional judgment in your defense.

Understand the process

Take a few minutes to look over this page and get to know the next steps. The more you know about the litigation process, the better.

Meet your team

Take some time to meet your legal team. While your case is pending, you will likely talk to several members of the firm, including your attorney, paralegals, and administrative assistants.

Got questions?

If this is the first time you have been involved in a lawsuit, you likely have questions. We've put together some frequently asked questions to assist you.

The litigation process

Getting sued can be an unsettling experience. But we're here to provide legal representation and help ensure your rights are protected under the law.
 Middle eastern man portrait
  1. What is litigation?

    Contesting a legal action in court.

  2. First steps

    How to begin the initial steps of your defense. Your legal team will ask you to fill out a detailed questionnaire. Someone from our office will speak with you to discuss the details of your case.

  3. Discovery

    What we need to help prepare your case. We will collect information relevant to your case during the "discovery" phase. You may be asked to give a deposition. But your lawyer will be with you.

  4. Resolution

    The different ways your case can be finalized. If appropriate, we'll meet with the plaintiff's lawyer to discuss the possibility of settlement. Each case is different. Most do not go to trial and are settled or dismissed.

Glossary

  • Discovery
    When attorneys learn about their client's case and the other side's case by examining all of the relevant documents, photos, emails, etc.
  • Deposition
    A meeting with your attorney in front of a court reporter where you will give your testimony under oath administered by a court reporter.
  • Mediation
    A meeting before an independent third party who attempts to work out a settlement between the parties. If the case does not settle, it continues through the court system.

Staff counsel attorneys

Here's the team of attorneys available to defend you.

Staff counsel headshot 

Holly W. Carroll

Lead Counsel

University of Florida, B.S.
Nova University , J.D.

Practice Location: Fort Lauderdale, FL
Email me
Phone: 954-254-4206

Staff counsel headshot 

Randall S. Goldberg

Lead Counsel

George Washington University, B.A.
Tulane Law School, J.D.

Practice Location:Ft. Lauderdale & Ft. Myers, FL
Email me
Phone: 786-266-3935

Staff counsel headshot 

Brian Goldstein

Lead Counsel

Florida State University, B.A.
Florida Coastal School of Law, J.D.
University of Central Florida, M.P.A.

Practice Location: Miami, FL
Email me
Phone: 305-282-6475

Staff counsel headshot 

Ted M. Stephan

Lead Counsel

University of Florida, B.A.
University of Florida, J.D.

Practice Location: Orlando, FL
Email me
Phone: 407-236-0564

Staff counsel headshot 

Matthew Tucy

Lead Counsel

University of South Florida, B.A.
Barry University School of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Tampa, FL
Email me
Phone: 813-505-8725

Staff counsel headshot 

Aaron Baker

Attorney at Law

Dickinson College, B.A.
Roger Williams University, J.D.

Practice Location: Orlando, FL
Email me
Phone: 352-214-9496

Staff counsel headshot 

KeiErica Baker

Attorney at Law

University of South Florida, B.A.
Western Michigan University Cooley Law School, J.D.

Practice Location: Tampa, FL
Email me
Phone: 813-260-0127

Staff counsel headshot 

Justin R. Barger

Attorney at Law

University of North Florida, B.A.
St. Thomas School of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Fort Myers, FL
Email me
Phone: 239-428-9164

Staff counsel headshot 

Oscar Bastardo

Attorney at Law

Florida State University, B.A.
Florida Coastal School of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Fort Myers, FL
Email me
Phone: 813-470-0931

Staff counsel headshot 

Madel Bermudez

Attorney at Law

Florida Atlantic University, B.A.
Nova Southeastern University Shepard Broad Law Center, J.D.

Practice Location: Fort Lauderdale, FL
Email me
Phone: 561-281-7149

Staff counsel headshot 

Charles Reid Bierer

Attorney at Law

Furman University, B.A.
Dickinson School of Law, J.D.
Bowling Green State University, M.A.

Practice Location: Jacksonville, FL
Email me
Phone: 954-646-9602

Staff counsel headshot 

Amanda Bond

Attorney at Law

University of Central Florida, B.A.
University of Miami School of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Fort Lauderdale, FL
Email me
Phone: 772-775-4305

Staff counsel headshot

Joseph Burke

Attorney at Law

Boston University, B.A.
University of Miami School of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Miami, FL
Email me
Phone: 305-213-7253

Staff counsel headshot 

Bryan Burkhardt

Attorney at Law

Florida Atlantic University, B.S.
Nova Southeastern University, J.D.

Practice Location: Fort Lauderdale, FL
Email me
Phone: 954-319-3082

Staff counsel headshot 

Chelsea R. Cangiano

Attorney at Law

Florida State University, B.A.
Nova Southeastern University, J.D.

Practice Location: Miami, FL
Email me
Phone: 305-319-9416

Staff counsel headshot 

Angelina Carmella Capece

Attorney at Law

Nova Southeastern, Shepard Broad Law Center, J.D.

Practice Location: Fort Lauderdale, FL
Email me
Phone: 954-235-2599

Staff counsel headshot 

Darrin Chambers

Attorney at Law

University of Central Florida, B.A.
Barry University School of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Orlando, FL
Email me
Phone: 407-969-5378

Staff counsel headshot 

Tino F. Cimato

Attorney at Law

Canisius College, B.A.
Catholic University of America – Columbus School of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Orlando, FL
Email me
Phone: 239-641-9239

Staff counsel headshot 

Ian L. Clarke

Attorney at Law

George Mason University, B.A.
Stetson University College of Law, J.D., L.L.M, MBA
Florida Gulf Coast University, MPA

Practice Location: Fort Myers, FL
Email me
Phone: 239-565-2133

Staff counsel headshot 

Philip A. Coffaro

Attorney at Law

University of Florida, B.A.
Stetson University College of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Orlando, FL
Email me
Phone: 407-496-1378

Staff counsel headshot 

Marielys Concepcion

Attorney at Law

University of Miami, B.A.
St. Thomas University, J.D.

Practice Location: Miami, FL
Email me
Phone: 305-462-5486

Staff counsel headshot 

Andrew Dugue

Attorney at Law

Boston College, B.A.
University of Miami School of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Jacksonville, FL
Email me
Phone: 904-210-6040

Staff counsel headshot 

Manon Ferdani

Attorney at Law

Nova Southeastern University, B.A.
St. Thomas School of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Miami, FL
Email me
Phone: 954-552-4061

Staff counsel headshot 

Matthew L. Fernandez

Attorney at Law

University of Florida, B.S.
University of Florida, J.D.

Practice Location: Tampa, FL
Email me
Phone: 877-250-3378
Mobile: 954-256-3378

Donna Ferrell

Attorney at Law

City College of the City of New York, B.A.
Brooklyn Law School, J.D.

Practice Location: Tampa, FL
Email me
Phone: 813-476-1452

George Geogymon

Attorney at Law

University of Florida, B.S.
Nova Southeastern University, J.D.
Nova Southeastern University, M.B.A.

Practice Location: Tampa, FL
Email me
Phone: 813-947-3255

Staff counsel headshot 

Paul R. Godfrey

Attorney at Law

Baylor University, B.A.
Florida Coastal School of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Tampa, FL
Email me
Phone: 813-536-9302

Staff counsel headshot 

Andrew A. Goodenough

Attorney at Law

Oakland University, B.A.
University of Detroit Mercy School of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Tampa, FL
Email me
Phone: 813-505-4739

Staff counsel headshot 

Angela Greenwalt

Attorney at Law

Christendom College, B.A.
Ave Maria School of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Tampa, FL
Email me
Phone: 813-260-0264

Staff counsel headshot 

Philistine Hamdan

Attorney at Law

University of South Florida, B.A.
Cooley Law School, J.D.

Practice Location: Tampa, FL
Email me
Phone: 813-334-4179

Staff counsel headshot 

Gabriel Hawa

Attorney at Law

Florida International University, B.A.
St. Thomas University, J.D.

Practice Location: Miami, FL
Email me
Phone: 305-439-9531

Staff counsel headshot 

Yolande Henry

Attorney at Law

University of the West Indies, LLB.
St. Thomas University, J.D.

Practice Location: Miami, FL
Email me
Phone: 786-795-7928

Staff counsel headshot 

Priscilla Hernandez

Attorney at Law

Nova Southeastern University, B.S.
St. Thomas University College of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Miami, FL
Email me
Phone: 954-604-4061

Staff counsel headshot 

Michael Jimenez

Attorney at Law

University of Florida, B.A.
Florida Agricultural and Mechanical University College of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Orlando, FL
Email me
Phone: 407-403-0863

Staff counsel headshot 

Ritisha Khatri

Attorney at Law

University of Central Florida, B.A.
Florida State University College of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Orlando, FL
Email me

Staff counsel headshot 

Shari Kikam

Attorney at Law

Florida State University, B.A.
University of Miami School of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Miami, FL
Email me
Phone: 954-830-7926

Staff counsel headshot 

Kaitlyn Konecny

Attorney at Law

Florida State University, B.A.
Stetson University College of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Miami, FL
Email me
Mobile: 954-412-1406

Staff counsel headshot 

Amanda Lee-Peterson

Attorney at Law

Texas Tech University, B.A.
Barry University School of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Tampa, FL
Email me
Phone: 813-205-9287

Staff counsel headshot 

Kia J. Love

Attorney at Law

Florida A&M University, B.A.
North Carolina Central University School of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Broward County, FL
Email me
Phone: 954-408-7253

Christopher J. Martin

Attorney at Law

University of Central Florida, B.S.
Barry University School of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Orlando, FL
Email me
Phone: 407-222-2603

Staff counsel headshot 

Tacarra Martin

Attorney at Law

St. Petersburg College, B.A.
Western Michigan University Thomas M. Cooley School of Law, J.D.
University of Phoenix, M.B.A.

Practice Location: Tampa, FL
Email me
Phone: 813-382-3020

Staff counsel headshot 

James B. McGee, III

Attorney at Law

University of Florida, B.A.
Stetson University College of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Tampa, FL
Email me
Phone: 727-338-7963

Staff counsel headshot 

Timothy McHaffie

Attorney at Law

University of Florida, B.A.
Stetson Univeristy College of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Tampa, FL
Email me
Phone: 813-508-5418

Staff counsel headshot 

Juliana P. Millon

Attorney at Law

Florida International University, B.S.
St. Thomas School of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Miami, FL
Email me
Phone: 786-516-5078

Staff counsel headshot 

Esther Mukiama

Attorney at Law

Middle Georgia State University, B.S.
Barry University, Dwayne O. Andreas School of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Orlando, FL
Email me
Phone: 407-741-3538

Tamara Nanes

Attorney at Law

University of Florida, B.A.
University of Miami School of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Miami, FL
Email me
Phone: 786-804-2310

Staff counsel headshot 

Joanna S. Opato

Attorney at Law

Stetson University, B.S.
University of Miami School of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Orlando, FL
Email me
Phone: 407-428-0341

Staff counsel headshot 

Jerrad Patterson

Attorney at Law

Florida Atlantic University, B.A.
Florida A&M University College of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Jacksonville, FL
Email me
Phone: 904-793-5408

Staff counsel headshot 

Tammy Pitiriciu

Attorney at Law

University of Miami, B.A.
Florida International University College of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Miami, FL
Email me
Phone: 954-249-0380

Staff counsel headshot 

Miranda Ramedia

Attorney at Law

University of Florida, B.S.
Stetson University College of Law, J.D.
Stetson University, M.B.A.

Practice Location: Tampa, FL
Email me
Phone: 813-205-7149

Staff counsel headshot 

Ryan Reed

Attorney at Law

Ohio State University, B.A.
Stetson University College of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Orlando, FL
Email me
Phone: 407-491-3087

Staff counsel headshot 

Andrew Riordan

Attorney at Law

University of New Mexico, B.A.
Ave Maria School of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Fort Myers, FL
Email me
Phone: 239-464-8659

Staff counsel headshot 

Stephanie Weber Ritt

Attorney at Law

Marymount Manhattan College, B.F.A.
Stetson University College of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Tampa, FL
Email me
Phone: 727-247-6704

Staff counsel headshot

Diana Rodriguez

Attorney at Law

University of Texas – Arlington, B.A.
Barry University School of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Miami, FL
Email me
Phone: 954-743-9515

Staff counsel headshot 

Lauren Schroeder

Attorney at Law

Birmingham Southern College, B.A.
Florida A & M University College of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Tampa, FL
Email me
Phone: 727-390-7549

Staff counsel headshot 

Jennifer Schulte

Attorney at Law

University of Central Florida, B.A.
Florida A & M University College of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Orlando, FL
Email me
Phone: 407-462-8824

Staff counsel headshot 

Benjamin L. Scutellaro

Attorney at Law

Florida Atlantic University, B.A.
Nova Southeastern University, J.D.

Practice Location: Fort Lauderdale, FL
Email me
Phone: 954-762-1184

Staff counsel headshot 

Manshi Shah

Attorney at Law

University of Miami, B.S.
UIC John Marshall Law School f/k/a John Marshall Law School, J.D.

Practice Location: Fort Lauderdale, FL
Email me
Phone: 561-236-6943

Staff counsel headshot 

Dainius Simpkins

Attorney at Law

University of Florida, B.A.
University of Florida, J.D.

Practice Location: Orlando, FL
Email me
Phone: 321-230-5123

Staff counsel headshot 

Jason D. Skura

Attorney at Law

SUNY at New Paltz, B.A.
Nova Southeastern University, Shepard Broad College of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Miami, FL
Email me
Phone: 954-242-0796

Staff counsel headshot 

Lucas R. Smith-Marin

Attorney at Law

Wright State University, B.A.
Cooley Law School, J.D.
Cooley Law School, LL.M.

Practice Location: Tampa, FL
Email me
Phone: 813-791-9815

Staff counsel headshot 

Alyson L. Sommers

Attorney at Law

Florida State University, B.A.
University of Florida, J.D.

Practice Location: Jacksonville, FL
Email me
Phone: 904-318-8132

Staff counsel headshot 

Steven K. Sorenson

Attorney at Law

Florida State University, B.S.
University of Florida, Levin College of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Fort Lauderdale, FL
Email me
Phone: 561-617-6881

Staff counsel headshot 

Jacqulyn Stinson

Attorney at Law

University of Central Florida, B.S.
Ave Maria School of Lawl, J.D.

Practice Location: Orlando, FL
Email me
Phone: 312-684-3027

Staff counsel headshot 

Jennifer Thompson

Attorney at Law

Stetson University, B.A.
University of Miami, J.D.

Practice Location: Fort Lauderdale, FL
Email me
Phone: 754-226-8256

Staff counsel headshot 

Megan Tobin

Attorney at Law

University of Tampa, B.A.
Barry University School of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Tampa, FL
Email me
Phone: 727-739-6176

Staff counsel headshot 

Marielena Tynan

Attorney at Law

Long Island University, B.A.
Nova Southeastern University Shepard Broad Law Center, J.D.

Practice Location: Orlando, FL
Email me
Phone: 312-272-1676

Staff counsel headshot 

Mauricio Vargas

Attorney at Law

Florida International University, B.A.
NSU Shepard Broad College of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Miami, FL
Email me
Phone: 561-591-9038

Staff counsel headshot 

Maria Vazquez

Attorney at Law

University of Virginia, B.A.
Western New England University School of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Orlando, FL
Email me
Phone: 407-236-0567
Mobile: 407-619-0729

Staff counsel headshot 

Ashley Ward-Singleton

Attorney at Law

Florida State University, B.S.
Stetson University College of Law, J.D.
Stetson University College of Law, M.B.A.

Practice Location: Tampa, FL
Email me
Phone: 727-318-2794

Staff counsel headshot 

Hilary Wilson

Attorney at Law

University of Georgia, B.S.
Florida Coastal School of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Jacksonville, FL
Email me
Phone: 904-705-9844

Staff counsel headshot 

Shaconna J. Wright

Attorney at Law

University of Central Florida, B.S.
Florida A&M University College of Law, J.D.
University of Central Florida, M.S.

Practice Location: Orlando, FL
Email me
Phone: 407-236-0567
Mobile: 407-619-0729

Support staff

Administrative assistants and paralegals work closely with staff attorneys. Please contact us with any questions, concerns, or other issues you may have.

Fax: 877-838-0840

Frequently asked questions

Do you have some general questions? Our FAQs might help. But if you don't find your answers below, feel free to contact our office. Your attorney and the attorney's support staff will be happy to assist you.

Contact

Please contact us with any questions, concerns, or other issues you may have.

Law Office of Carroll, Stephan, Tucy, Goldstein and Goldberg

Mailing Address Only:
4443 Lyons Road
Suite 206
Coconut Creek, Florida 33073

Fax: 877-838-0840

© 2026 Allstate Insurance