Law offices of Rachel Vicari

This office is not a partnership or a corporation.

Main number: 908-653-2100
Wooden gavel with Allstate logo

We're here to help

The attorneys in this office limit their practice to defending lawsuits against people like you who are insured by Allstate or one of their subsidiaries. They represent you and will exercise independent professional judgment in your defense.

Understand the process

Take a few minutes to look over this page and get to know the next steps. The more you know about the litigation process, the better.

Meet your team

Take some time to meet your legal team. While your case is pending, you will likely talk to several members of the firm, including your attorney, paralegals, and administrative assistants.

Got questions?

If this is the first time you have been involved in a lawsuit, you likely have questions. We've put together some frequently asked questions to assist you.

The litigation process

Getting sued can be an unsettling experience. But we're here to provide legal representation and help ensure your rights are protected under the law.
 Middle eastern man portrait
  1. What is litigation?

    Contesting a legal action in court.

  2. First steps

    How to begin the initial steps of your defense. Your legal team will ask you to fill out a detailed questionnaire. Someone from our office will speak with you to discuss the details of your case.

  3. Discovery

    What we need to help prepare your case. We will collect information relevant to your case during the "discovery" phase. You may be asked to give a deposition. But your lawyer will be with you.

  4. Resolution

    The different ways your case can be finalized. If appropriate, we'll meet with the plaintiff's lawyer to discuss the possibility of settlement. Each case is different. Most do not go to trial and are settled or dismissed.

Glossary

  • Discovery
    When attorneys learn about their client's case and the other side's case by examining all of the relevant documents, photos, emails, etc.
  • Deposition
    A meeting with your attorney in front of a court reporter where you will give your testimony under oath administered by a court reporter.
  • Mediation
    A meeting before an independent third party who attempts to work out a settlement between the parties. If the case does not settle, it continues through the court system.

Staff counsel attorneys

Here's the team of attorneys available to defend you.

Staff counsel headshot 

Rachel Vicari

Lead Counsel

West Virginia University, B.A.
University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill School of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Wall, NJ
Email me
Phone: 609-789-3493

Staff counsel headshot

Xenia Calderon

Lead Counsel

Montclair State University, B.A.
Rutgers School of Law Newark, J.D.

Practice Location: Cranford, NJ
Email me
Phone: 908-653-2138
Mobile: 862-621-3804

Staff counsel headshot 

Maria O. Rodriguez

Lead Counsel

LaSalle University, B.A.
Widener University , J.D.

Practice Location: New Jersey
Email me
Phone: 856-654-5062

Staff counsel headshot 

Ahmed Adam

Attorney at Law

Rutgers University, B.A.
North Carolina Central University School of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: New Jersey
Email me
Phone: 732-737-5219

Staff counsel headshot 

Nida Sayeed Alam

Attorney at Law

Stony Brook University, B.A.
Charlotte School of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Union County
Email me
Phone: 551-330-6534

Staff counsel headshot 

David B. Angeluzzi

Attorney at Law

Loyola College, B.A.
Marquette University Law School, J.D.

Practice Location: New Jersey
Email me
Phone: 862-221-0581

Staff counsel headshot 

Suzanne Ciobanu Baidon

Attorney at Law

University of Pennsylvania, B.A.
Rutgers University School of Law-Newark, J.D.

Practice Location: Northern, New Jersey
Email me
Phone: 201-723-9149

Staff counsel headshot 

Michele F. Benenato

Attorney at Law

Rutgers University, B.A.
Seton Hall University School of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Cranford, NJ
Email me
Phone: 908-653-2191
Mobile: 862-621-3607

Staff counsel headshot 

Khaleah Buffalo

Attorney at Law

East Stroudsburg University, B.A.
Southern University Law Center, J.D.

Practice Location: Southern New Jersey
Email me
Phone: 856-562-2358

Staff counsel headshot 

John C. Ciabattari

Attorney at Law

University of Minnesota, B.A.
New York University School of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Cranford, NJ
Email me
Phone: 908-653-2115
Mobile: 201-286-2465

Staff counsel headshot 

Andrea S. D'Eletto

Attorney at Law

St. John's University, B.S.
Rutgers University, J.D.

Practice Location: New Jersey
Email me
Phone: 732-751-3964
Mobile: 732-614-5764

Staff counsel headshot 

Nicole M. Downs

Attorney at Law

University of Maryland, B.S.
Widener University School of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: New Jersey
Email me
Phone: 856-642-2905
Phone: 856-266-7903

Staff counsel headshot 

Michael Forcino

Attorney at Law

Brooklyn College, B.A.
New York Law School, J.D.

Practice Location: Cranford, NJ
Email me
Phone: 908-653-2117
Mobile: 732-856-7270

Staff counsel headshot 

Mindy P. Fox

Attorney at Law

University of Pennsylvania, B.A.
Fordham Law School, J.D.

Practice Location: Hudson County
Email me
Phone: 908-548-3370

 

Christopher Hughes

Attorney at Law

Rutgers College, B.A.
Seton Hall Law School, J.D.

Practice Location: Passaic County, NJ
Email me
Phone: 551-580-2236

Staff counsel headshot 

Uwaila Igbokwe

Attorney at Law

Howard University, B.S.
Rutgers School of Law Camden, J.D.

Practice Location: Cranford, NJ
Email me
Phone: 908-653-2160
Mobile: 908-587-6174

Staff counsel headshot 

Brian James

Attorney at Law

Rutgers University, B.A.
Widener University School of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Southern New Jersey
Email me
Phone: 856-631-4439

Staff counsel headshot 

Monica Lloyd

Attorney at Law

University of California, San Diego, B.A.
Temple Law School, J.D.

Practice Location: New Jersey
Email me
Phone: 856-642-2593
Phone: 856-571-9309

Staff counsel headshot 

Shane Mallon

Attorney at Law

Seton Hall University, B.A.
Pace University School of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Cranford, NJ
Email me
Phone: 908-653-2122
Mobile: 862-216-5182

Staff counsel headshot 

Janelle C. L. Matthews

Attorney at Law

Haverford College, B.A.
Georgetown University Law Center, J.D.

Practice Location: Middlesex, New Jersey
Email me
Phone: 908-251-1542

Staff counsel headshot 

Brittany McCloskey

Attorney at Law

Arcadia University, B.S.
Widener University School of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Southern New Jersey
Email me
Phone: 856-323-3576

Staff counsel headshot 

Debra Tyukody Mirandi

Attorney at Law

Douglass College, B.A.
Rutgers School of Law Newark, J.D.

Practice Location: Cranford, NJ
Email me
Phone: 908-653-2132
Mobile: 201-310-4631

Staff counsel headshot 

Denise M. Neuffer

Attorney at Law

State University of New York at Albany, B.A.
Albany Law School of Union University, J.D.

Practice Location: New Jersey
Email me
Phone: 732-751-3963
Mobile: 732-456-9793

Staff counsel headshot 

Richard Oldfield

Attorney at Law

Cook College, Rutgers University, B.S.
Seton Hall University School of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Northern, NJ
Email me
Phone: 908-653-2112
Mobile: 201-214-9396

Staff counsel headshot 

Natalie Pena

Attorney at Law

St. Peter's College, B.S.
Rutgers Law School, J.D.

Practice Location: Cranford, NJ
Email me
Phone: 201-334-6770

Staff counsel headshot 

Susan D. Pontoriero

Attorney at Law

Rutgers College, B.A., B.S.
Seton Hall Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Mercer and Atlantic Counties
Email me
Phone: 732-278-1341

Staff counsel headshot 

Gabrielle Pribula

Attorney at Law

Fairfield University, B.S.
St. John's University School of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Cranford, NJ
Email me
Phone: 908-653-2139
Mobile: 973-307-8390

Staff counsel headshot 

Stephanie A. Reynolds

Attorney at Law

Rutgers University, B.A. & M.A.
Seton Hall Law School, J.D.

Practice Location: Cranford, NJ
Email me
Phone: 908-653-2180
Mobile: 973-997-7271

Staff counsel headshot 

Cindy Satter

Attorney at Law

The Pennsylvania State University, B.A.
Boston University School of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Cranford, NJ
Email me
Phone: 732-513-8569

Staff counsel headshot 

Theo Tsakalis

Attorney at Law

Rowan University, B.A.
Widener University School of Law, J.D.

Practice Location: Essex County, NJ
Email me
Phone: 551-284-9380

Staff counsel headshot 

Joseph Verga

Attorney at Law

Hamilton College, B.A.
Albany Law School, J.D.

Practice Location: Middlesex County, New Jersey
Email me
Phone: 732-216-5091

Staff counsel headshot 

Jane Ann E. Whitchurch

Attorney at Law

Rutgers University, B.A.
New York Law School, J.D.

Practice Location: Cranford, NJ
Email me
Phone: 551-502-4197

Staff counsel headshot 

Crystal M. Wyatt

Attorney at Law

Rutgers University, B.A.
North Carolina Central University, J.D.

Practice Location: Cranford, NJ
Email me
Phone: 908-653-2193
Mobile: 908-487-8392

Support staff

Administrative assistants and paralegals work closely with staff attorneys. Please contact us with any questions, concerns, or other issues you may have.

Main Number: 908-653-2100

Toll-Free: 877-895-5691

Fax: 877-772-5142

Frequently asked questions

Do you have some general questions? Our FAQs might help. But if you don't find your answers below, feel free to contact our office. Your attorney and the attorney's support staff will be happy to assist you.

Contact

Please contact us with any questions, concerns, or other issues you may have.

Law offices of Rachel Vicari

Signature Corporate Center
100 Walnut Avenue
Suite 602,
Clark, NJ 07066

Main number: 908-653-2100

Toll-Free: 877-895-5691

Fax: 877-772-5142

Toll free: 1-877-895-5691

© 2026 Allstate Insurance